Fjord

An immigrant Romanian family living in Norway is subject to an investigation and faces the scrutiny of the local judicial system.

Cristian Mungiu’s ‘Fjord’, his second film to win the Palme d’Or at Cannes, is a gripping and deliberately provocative drama that raises some fascinating questions about cultural differences, religion and the limits of multiculturalism. Loosely inspired by the real life case of the Bodnariu family, it follows Mihai (Sebastian Stan) and Lisbet (Renate Reinsve), a Romanian-Norwegian couple who have recently moved from Romania to Norway with their five children. Their devout Christian beliefs and traditional approach to parenting put them at odds with their more liberal neighbours, and when their eldest daughter arrives at school with bruises, the authorities become involved, setting off a chain of events that threatens to tear the family apart.

What I really liked about ‘Fjord’ was its willingness to tackle a difficult moral dilemma, and to challenge the audience to consider perspectives they might instinctively disagree with. As migration brings together people from increasingly different cultural and religious backgrounds, how do we accommodate those whose values and beliefs are fundamentally at odds with our own? Where should the line be drawn between respecting cultural differences and protecting children? Mungiu isn’t afraid to ask these uncomfortable questions, and I particularly liked how the film explores the dogmatism on both sides. The family’s religious convictions are central to the conflict, but the film also suggests that those who consider themselves progressive and secular can be every bit as rigid in their beliefs about how other people should live. As someone who isn’t religious, I thought this was a particularly interesting aspect of the film, and one that demonstrates its moral complexity.

That said, I did have some reservations about how the story develops. I don’t know enough about the Norwegian child protection system to judge how realistic the proceedings are, but I found it difficult to believe that events would escalate quite so dramatically on the basis of what initially appears to be a single incident. For a film that is otherwise so interested in exploring the grey areas, the apparent disproportionate response of the authorities makes it rather easier to sympathise with the family than perhaps it should be. There are also moments when Mungiu seems a little too keen to make his point, particularly with the aggressively liberal neighbours and some of the more extreme protesters outside the courtroom. These elements felt a bit on the nose to me, and occasionally detracted from what is otherwise a much more nuanced examination of the issues involved. Nevertheless, I was gripped by ‘Fjord’ from beginning to end, and despite its substantial running time, I never felt it dragged. Mungiu handles the escalating tension brilliantly, while Stan and Reinsve are both excellent, bringing plenty of conviction to characters whose actions and beliefs won’t always be easy for audiences to accept. Kudos as well for managing to find actors who were so adept at playing infuriating bureaucrats as well! In a cinematic landscape where so many films play it safe, I particularly enjoy and admire a film that is so willing and bold enough to provoke disagreement, particularly when dealing with subjects that are increasingly difficult to discuss without people immediately taking sides. I don’t think every aspect of the story is entirely convincing, and at times it simplifies some of the very questions it wants us to wrestle with, but ‘Fjord’ does prompt you to think and I thought it was really good.

Rating: 4/5

Directed By: Cristian Mungiu

Starring: Sebastian Stan, Renate Reinsve, Lisa Carlehed, Henrikke Lund-Olsen, Vanessa Ceban, Jonathan Ciprian Breazu, Ellen Dorrit Petersen, Lisa Loven Kongsli and Markus Tønseth

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt35410859/

Leave a Reply